How to analyze a fix and flip deal
A flip works or fails on three numbers: what the house sells for after the work, what the work costs, and what you pay for it. Everything else, profit, holding, the loan, and the backup exit, is arithmetic on those three. This page walks the steps in the order a deal report runs them, on one invented house, and links to the guide that goes deeper on each step. The comps, the house, and the asking price below are invented. They are not closed sales and not a market average.
Step 1: After-repair value from sold comps
The after-repair value, or ARV, is what the house should sell for once the repairs are done. It comes from closed sales of similar, already-updated houses nearby, not from the list price and not from an automated estimate. Say three invented sales qualify: $195,000, $200,000, and $212,000. Sorted, the middle one is $200,000. That is the hand estimate. A deal report goes further and weights each comp by how recent, how close, and how similar it is before it takes a weighted median. The ARV estimate guide explains why the median and the average of the same three sales differ, and how to pull comps covers the recency, distance, and similarity weights. Drop sales that are not like the subject before you sort anything; the guide to which comps to throw out shows what one unlike sale does to the number. Keep the ARV separate from what the house is worth today in its current condition; the as-is value versus ARV guide shows why subtracting both double-counts condition.
Step 2: The repair budget
The invented house is a 1,000 square foot single-family home built in 2010. A deal report prices rehab in three tiers from base rates of $20, $40, and $80 a square foot, then multiplies by an age factor and a property-type factor. A house this age and type gets a factor of 1.00 on both, so the tiers are $20,000 cosmetic, $40,000 moderate, and $80,000 gut. The report selects the moderate tier by default, so this example uses $40,000. The rehab cost per square foot guide shows the factors on a house where they are not 1.00.
A tier is a starting budget, not a bid. Before you sign, walk the house and write each line: quantity, unit price, and who quoted it. The line-item repair estimate guide builds that list on this same house and compares it with the $40,000 tier, and the scope of work checklist is the room list to walk.
Step 3: The maximum allowable offer
The maximum allowable offer, or MAO, is the most you can pay and still keep the margins you set. The report uses a 25/5/3 formula: ARV minus repairs, minus 25 percent of ARV for profit, 5 percent for closing, and 3 percent for holding. On this example that is $200,000 − $40,000 − $50,000 − $10,000 − $6,000 = $94,000. You can type the same inputs, or your own percents, into the MAO calculator.
The 70% rule is the quick screen: 70 percent of ARV minus repairs. Here that is $140,000 − $40,000 = $100,000, which is $6,000 more than the itemized offer. The two agree on direction and disagree on dollars, because the 70% rule folds profit, closing, and holding into one 30 percent. The 70% rule examples set both side by side on three deals, and when the 70% rule is too high covers the cases where paying the screen price still loses money.
Step 4: Compare the offer with the asking price
Say the invented listing asks $105,000. The $94,000 offer is $11,000 under it. That gap is a negotiation, not a reason to raise the offer. The offer came from the ARV and the repairs; the asking price came from the seller. The MAO versus list price guide shows how a deal report scores that spread, and the days on market guide shows how a longer expected sale lowers the offer again.
Step 5: Project the profit
Buying at $94,000, the flip projection adds buyer closing of 3 percent of the purchase price ($2,820), holding of 0.5 percent of the purchase price a month for 6 months ($2,820), and takes seller closing of 6 percent of the ARV ($12,000) out of the sale. Total investment is $94,000 + $40,000 + $2,820 + $2,820 = $139,640. Net proceeds are $200,000 − $12,000 = $188,000. Profit is $188,000 − $139,640 = $48,360, an ROI of 34.6 percent on the money in. The fix and flip profit guide walks each line. The closing costs guide explains why the offer reserves 5 percent while the projection charges 3 percent on the buy and 6 percent on the sale, and the holding costs guide does the same for the 3 percent reserve and the 0.5 percent monthly line. Try the numbers in the house flipping calculator.
Step 6: Add the loan
The $48,360 is a cash profit. It has no interest and no points in it. The hard-money preset on the signed-in financing card is 10 percent down on purchase plus rehab, a 12 percent rate, and interest-only payments. On $134,000 of project cost that is a $120,600 loan and $1,206 a month. Six months is $7,236, which brings the profit to $41,124 and the ROI to 28.0 percent. The hard money interest guide has the full arithmetic. A real term sheet can add limits the preset does not: a cap on the purchase share, a cap tied to ARV, and draws on the rehab money. The loan to cost versus loan to ARV guide works an invented term sheet on this house.
Step 7: Check the backup exit
If the house does not sell, can you keep it? The refinance check in a deal report assumes a loan of 75 percent of ARV: $150,000 here. Cash in is purchase plus rehab, $134,000, so the refinance would return all of it and $16,000 more. The BRRRR refinance guide shows that math and what happens when the loan falls short. A deal with a workable second exit is a safer deal at the same offer.
The seven numbers on one page
- ARV: $200,000, the middle of three invented sold comps.
- Repairs: $40,000, the moderate tier at $40 a square foot on 1,000 square feet.
- Maximum allowable offer: $94,000 by 25/5/3, against $100,000 by the 70% rule.
- Asking price: $105,000, so the offer is $11,000 under it.
- Cash profit: $48,360, an ROI of 34.6 percent.
- Profit with six months of hard-money interest: $41,124, an ROI of 28.0 percent.
- Refinance at 75 percent of ARV: $150,000, which returns the $134,000 in.
If any one of these looks wrong, fix it at its own step and rerun the steps after it. A high ARV inflates the offer, the profit, and the refinance all at once.
Questions
What order should I run the numbers in?
After-repair value first, then the repair budget, then the offer. Profit, holding, financing, and the exit check all start from those three numbers, so a mistake in the ARV moves every line after it.
Is the 70% rule enough to make an offer?
It is a screen. On the invented example it allows $100,000, while the itemized 25/5/3 offer allows $94,000. Run both, and use the itemized one when you have real closing and holding figures.
Are the dollar figures on this page real sales?
No. The comps, the house, and the asking price are invented so each subtraction can be checked by hand. They are not closed sales, a lender quote, or a market average.
To run every step on a real address, open the sample analysis after you sign up, then paste an address or a listing link. The sample is an example report with invented figures. The sample analysis is created after signup.