As-is value versus after-repair value
As-is value and after-repair value answer different questions. As-is value is what a house sells for in the condition it is in. After-repair value is what a repaired house sells for. Mixing the two, or subtracting a rehab budget from both, is how an offer gets built on a double count. This page uses two invented medians. Distressed sales of similar houses center at $140,000. Repaired sales center at $210,000. Neither figure is a listing you can tour. They are here so the gap has a dollar amount.
The gap is not the rehab budget
The repaired median minus the distressed median is $70,000. The rehab budget you are willing to sign is an invented $48,000. The gap is $22,000 larger than the budget. That $22,000 is not found money. It is the room, before you have priced closing and holding, between buying a broken house and selling a fixed one. If your rehab really is $70,000, then the budget matches the gap and the room is zero before costs. If your rehab is $48,000, do not tell yourself the $70,000 gap proved the budget. The gap is a statement about two sets of sales. The budget is a statement about the scope. They meet in the offer. They are not the same line.
The 70 percent rule belongs on the repaired number, because that is the number a retail buyer pays after the work. Seventy percent of $210,000 is $147,000. Minus the $48,000 rehab, the offer is $99,000. You can type a single sold price of $210,000 and a rehab of $48,000 into the ARV and 70% rule calculator and read $99,000. The 25/5/3 offer on the MAO calculator is lower. Profit is $52,500, closing is $10,500, holding is $6,300. The offer is $210,000 minus $48,000 minus $52,500 minus $10,500 minus $6,300, which is $92,700. The gap between the two screens is $6,300, which is 3 percent of the ARV, not 3 percent of the as-is value.
Subtracting rehab from the as-is price
Take the distressed median of $140,000 and subtract the same $48,000 rehab. You get $92,000. That looks like a careful offer and it is a second haircut for the same condition. The $140,000 already came from houses that were not repaired. The buyers of those houses paid $140,000 knowing the work was still ahead, or knowing they would live with it. Subtracting your rehab again prices the work twice. $92,000 is $7,000 under the 70 percent offer and $700 under the 25/5/3 offer, but the coincidence of being “close” is not a reason to use it. Close to a real formula is not the formula. The Zestimate versus ARV page makes a cousin of this mistake: a current automated value is not the repaired value. An as-is sale is at least a sale. It is still the wrong sale for an ARV.
There is a legitimate use of the as-is number. It is a check that your contract is not wildly above what a distressed house actually trades for, and it is a check on whether your ARV comps were really repaired. If the “repaired” sales look like the distressed sales, you do not have a $210,000 ARV. You have one set of prices with two labels. The throw-out guide is how an unlike sale gets a label. A repaired sale in a set of as-is comps is unlike, and an as-is sale in a set of repaired comps is unlike. Do not average the two sets and call the middle an ARV.
Where the $22,000 goes
Buyer closing, seller closing, and holding are not inside the $48,000 rehab. On a purchase at the 70 percent offer of $99,000, buyer closing at 3 percent is $2,970. Seller closing at 6 percent of the $210,000 ARV is $12,600. Six months of holding at 0.5 percent of the purchase price per month is $99,000 times 0.005 times 6, which is $2,970. Those three lines sum to $18,540. They fit inside the $22,000 spread with $3,460 left, before any loan interest and before a wholesale fee. The spread was not profit. Most of it was the cost of getting from a broken house to a closed resale. Price those lines on the flip profit worksheet once the purchase price is chosen. This page only shows why they are not already paid by the gap between $140,000 and $210,000.
If the rehab comes in at $60,000 instead of $48,000, the 70 percent offer falls to $87,000 and the $22,000 spread falls to $10,000, which no longer covers the $18,540 of closing and holding just itemized. The as-is median did not change. The scope did. These two medians and this budget are invented.
Questions
Is the rehab budget the difference between as-is value and ARV?
Not in this example. The medians differ by $70,000 and the rehab budget is $48,000. The remaining $22,000 still has to cover closing, holding, and profit. Treating the whole gap as rehab understates the work or overstates the margin.
Can I subtract rehab from the as-is value to get an offer?
That subtracts condition twice. The as-is median already reflects disrepair. The ARV median reflects repaired houses. Rehab comes off the ARV screen, not off the as-is price.
run a full analysis free when the median you can do by hand is not enough. A full analysis weights the comps, adjusts beds and baths, and prices the repair tiers. The sample figures there are invented, the same way every dollar on this page is invented.