How to estimate repair costs by line item
A per-square-foot rehab tier gives you one number fast. A line-item estimate tells you what that number is buying. You need the first to screen a deal and the second before you sign, because a lender's draw schedule, a contractor's bid, and your own walk-through are all written in lines, not in dollars per square foot. This page builds a line-item budget on an invented house, adds a contingency, and compares the total with the tier a deal report would use. Every unit price below is invented. None is a market price or a price for any city.
What the tier gives you, and what it leaves out
A deal report prices rehab in three tiers from base rates of $20, $40, and $80 a square foot, multiplied by an age factor and a property-type factor. The house in this example is an invented 1,000 square foot single-family home built in 2010, where both factors are 1.00. That makes the tiers $20,000 cosmetic, $40,000 moderate, and $80,000 gut, and the report selects the moderate $40,000 by default. The report has no city price table and no line-item prices. It multiplies square feet by a rate. That is the right tool for comparing ten addresses in an afternoon, and the wrong tool for telling a contractor what to do. The rehab cost per square foot guide shows how the factors move on older houses and other property types.
How to write one line
Each line is a quantity times a unit price, plus the name of whoever gave you the price. Flooring is a good example: measure the rooms you will replace, not the whole house. If 800 of the 1,000 square feet get new floors at an invented $6 a square foot installed, the line is 800 × $6 = $4,800. Write it that way, with the quantity and the rate, so that when a second bid comes in at a different rate you can see which part changed. A line that only says “flooring $4,800” cannot be checked.
Some lines are a lump sum by nature: a water heater, a permit, a dumpster. Those are fine as one figure, but still write what is included. “Water heater, 40 gallon, installed, haul-away included” is a line. “Plumbing” is not. Keep labor and material together on a line when one bid covers both, and split them when you are buying the material yourself. The scope of work checklist is the room and system list to walk before you write any prices.
A worked line-item budget
Here is an invented walk-through of the 1,000 square foot house. The prices are made up for the arithmetic.
- Interior paint, walls and ceilings: $4,500.
- Flooring, 800 square feet at $6: $4,800.
- Kitchen cabinets, counters, sink, faucet, and appliances: $14,000.
- One full bathroom, tub surround, vanity, toilet, and tile: $8,000.
- Water heater, installed: $1,600.
- Electrical repairs after an electrician's inspection: $2,400.
- Roof repair and gutters: $3,500.
- Exterior cleanup, landscaping, and a dumpster: $1,700.
- Permits: $900.
The subtotal is $4,500 + $4,800 + $14,000 + $8,000 + $1,600 + $2,400 + $3,500 + $1,700 + $900 = $41,400. Add a contingency of 10 percent of the subtotal, $4,140, on its own line. The repair budget is $41,400 + $4,140 = $45,540. Divided by 1,000 square feet that is about $45.54 a square foot, a little above the $40 moderate rate and far below the $80 gut rate. The rehab contingency guide explains why the contingency is subtracted once and not padded into every room, and the kitchen and bath budget guide explains why you do not stack a kitchen line on top of a tier that already covers it.
What the line items do to the offer
The maximum allowable offer subtracts repairs dollar for dollar. Use an invented ARV of $200,000 and the report's 25/5/3 formula: 25 percent of ARV for profit, 5 percent for closing, and 3 percent for holding. With the $40,000 tier the offer is $200,000 − $40,000 − $50,000 − $10,000 − $6,000 = $94,000. With the $45,540 line-item budget it is $200,000 − $45,540 − $50,000 − $10,000 − $6,000 = $88,460. The offer drops by exactly the $5,540 the list added. Under the 70% rule the same change takes the offer from $100,000 to $140,000 − $45,540 = $94,460. Type either budget into the MAO calculator to see the offer move.
Use the higher of the tier and your list until you have written bids. A list that comes in lower than the tier may be a list with a room missing. Say a walk-through only found paint, flooring, and cleanup: $4,500 + $4,800 + $1,700 = $11,000, plus 10 percent is $12,100. The cosmetic tier on this house is $20,000. Before you offer on $12,100, check the roof, the water heater, the panel, and the sewer line, and price them or rule them out in writing. The cosmetic rehab guide shows what the lightest tier is meant to cover.
Lines that are easy to forget
Permits and the inspection that closes them. A dumpster, and a second one when demolition runs long. Utility reconnection on a vacant house. Final cleaning and staging before the listing photos. Small hardware: door handles, outlet covers, smoke detectors, and light fixtures add up across a whole house. On an older house, the systems behind the walls; the guide to rehab lines on a pre-1960 house lists the ones to inspect and price before you trust any tier.
Time is a line too, just not on this list. Every week the work runs long is another week of taxes, insurance, utilities, and loan interest. Those belong in holding, not in repairs, so keep them off the rehab budget and on the holding cost line.
Questions
Where do the unit prices on this page come from?
They are invented so the arithmetic can be checked. They are not a market average or a price list for any city. Replace each one with a written bid or a supplier quote for your house.
Should the offer use my line items or the per-square-foot tier?
Use the higher of the two until you have written bids. On the invented house the line items come to $45,540 against a $40,000 tier, so the offer uses $45,540 and drops by $5,540.
Is the contingency a line item?
Put it on its own line under the subtotal, not spread across the rooms. On this page it is 10 percent of the $41,400 subtotal, which is $4,140, and it is subtracted once from the offer with the rest of the repairs.
The rehab estimator multiplies the square footage you type by a tier's base rate in the browser, before the age and property-type factors a deal report adds. For the next step after repairs, see how to analyze a fix and flip deal.