When the 70% rule price is still too high
The 70 percent rule can print a price that is still too high, because the rule does not itemize buyer closing, seller closing, the month count, interest, or an assignment fee. It holds back 30 percent of ARV and hopes those things fit. This page starts from a clean 70 percent price and then puts one fee outside it, on invented numbers, so the damage is visible. After-repair value is $200,000. Rehab is $40,000. The 70 percent offer is $140,000 minus $40,000, which is $100,000. The 75 percent comparison is what happens when you give away five more points before these costs. This page stays at 70 and then adds a cost the percent forgot.
Pay the screen, and itemize anyway
Purchase is $100,000. Rehab is $40,000. Hold is 6 months. Buyer closing is 3 percent of $100,000, which is $3,000. Seller closing is 6 percent of $200,000, which is $12,000. Holding is 0.5 percent of the purchase per month times 6, which is $3,000. Cash in is $100,000 plus $40,000 plus $3,000 plus $3,000, which is $146,000. Net proceeds are $200,000 minus $12,000, which is $188,000. Profit is $42,000. ROI is $42,000 divided by $146,000. Times 1,000 that is 287.671, which rounds to 288, divided by 10 is 28.8 percent. The rule said $100,000 was allowed. The itemized flip says you make $42,000 if nothing else shows up. Interest is one of the things that has not shown up. This projection has no rate. A hard-money payment can consume part of the $42,000 and the rule will not have mentioned it.
A fee on top of the screen
An assignment fee of $10,000 paid in addition to the $100,000 makes the purchase $110,000. The rule’s price was supposed to be the whole check. You wrote a second check. Buyer closing is now 3 percent of $110,000, which is $3,300. Holding is $110,000 times 0.005 times 6, which is $3,300. Cash in is $110,000 plus $40,000 plus $3,300 plus $3,300, which is $156,600. Net proceeds stay $188,000, because the resale and the seller closing did not change. Profit is $31,400. ROI is $31,400 divided by $156,600. Times 1,000 that is 200.511, which rounds to 201, divided by 10 is 20.1 percent. The fee was $10,000. Profit fell by $10,600, because closing and holding are percents of the purchase and they rose with it. The profit-margin page uses a purchase chosen under the screen and gets a different ROI on purpose. Do not average 20.1 and 37.1 and call it a typical flip.
If the fee had been inside the $100,000, the wholesaler’s contract would be $90,000 and your all-in price would still be the screen. That is a fee the rule can tolerate, because you did not exceed it. The wholesaler checklist is how that wholesaler should have priced their side. Your job as the buyer is to notice when their fee is outside your screen. The MAO calculator on these inputs prints a 25/5/3 offer of $94,000, which is already $6,000 under the 70 percent price before any assignment. Paying $110,000 is $16,000 over that offer. The ARV and 70% rule calculator will keep printing $100,000 if you type a $200,000 median and $40,000 of rehab. It is a screen. It is not a defense of the second check.
Other ways the screen runs hot
Rehab that becomes $50,000 instead of $40,000 drops a true 70 percent price from $100,000 to $90,000. If you already signed at $100,000, you are $10,000 over the rule you claimed to follow, and the profit walk has to be rebuilt with both a higher purchase and a higher rehab. Holding for 9 months instead of 6 adds another $1,500 on the $100,000 purchase, because one more quarter at $500 a month is $1,500. The rule has no month field. A longer listing does not ask its permission. The holding cost guide is the 3 percent reserve versus the monthly line. Use the monthly line when you know the months. Use the 30 percent cushion only as the first no.
A negative answer is allowed. If the itemized profit is thin or negative, the 70 percent price was too high for the costs you can name, even though the rule printed a positive offer. $42,000 is not thin on this invented flip. $31,400 after a fee you did not have to pay is a worse deal than the screen advertised. These dollars are invented. The rates are the same flip rates used everywhere else on the site: 3 percent to buy, 6 percent to sell, half a percent of the purchase per month.
Questions
Does the 70 percent rule already include an assignment fee?
It includes nothing itemized. The 30 percent is a cushion for selling costs, holding, financing, and profit, without naming them. A fee you add on top of the 70 percent price is a second purchase cost the rule already assumed was inside the price.
What did the extra $10,000 do on this example?
Purchase went from $100,000 to $110,000. Profit went from $42,000 to $31,400. ROI went from 28.8 percent to 20.1 percent. Buyer closing and holding also rose, because both are percents of the purchase price.
run a full analysis free when the median you can do by hand is not enough. A full analysis weights the comps, adjusts beds and baths, and prices the repair tiers. The sample figures there are invented, the same way every dollar on this page is invented.