The 70% rule versus the 75% rule
Some buyers replace the 70 percent rule with a 75 percent rule. The shape is the same: a percent of after-repair value, minus rehab, rounded once. The only change is the percent. This page measures that change on invented numbers so the gap is a dollar amount you can check, not a slogan. The ARV and 70% rule calculator stays on 0.70. It will not silently become 0.75 because a buyer said they are flexible. If you need the itemized 25/5/3 offer instead, that is the MAO calculator.
Five points on a $220,000 ARV
After-repair value is $220,000. Rehab is $40,000. Seventy percent of $220,000 is $154,000. The 70 percent offer is $154,000 minus $40,000, which is $114,000. Seventy-five percent of $220,000 is $165,000. The 75 percent offer is $165,000 minus $40,000, which is $125,000. The buyer who uses 75 percent can pay $11,000 more and still be inside their own rule. $11,000 is 5 percent of $220,000. It is not 5 percent of the offer, and it is not 5 percent of rehab.
Move the rehab to $55,000 and leave the ARV alone. The 70 percent offer is $154,000 minus $55,000, which is $99,000. The 75 percent offer is $165,000 minus $55,000, which is $110,000. Both fell by $15,000. The gap is still $11,000. A contractor who comes in high does not make the two rules agree. The rules disagree by a slice of ARV. The contractor changes how much of that ARV is left to pay for the house.
The same five points on a smaller ARV
After-repair value is $180,000. Rehab is $55,000. Seventy percent is $126,000, so the offer is $126,000 minus $55,000, which is $71,000. Seventy-five percent is $135,000, so the offer is $135,000 minus $55,000, which is $80,000. The gap is $9,000, which is 5 percent of $180,000. The rehab happened to be $55,000 in both this deal and the sensitivity above. That is a coincidence of the example, not a rule that rehab and the gap are related. On $180,000 the five points are simply a smaller pile of dollars.
If you wholesale to a 75 percent buyer, the extra $9,000 is extra room under their ceiling. It is not extra profit until you know your contract price. A contract at the 70 percent offer of $71,000 leaves a $9,000 spread under the 75 percent offer of $80,000, before any other fee math. A contract at $80,000 leaves no spread at all for a buyer who stops at 75, and it is already $9,000 over a buyer who stops at 70. The 70 percent worked examples keep the screen at 70 and compare it with 25/5/3. This page only compares 70 with 75. Do not add the 3 percent gap from that page on top of the 5 percent gap here. They are different pairs of formulas.
Who the higher percent belongs to
The higher percent is the end buyer’s rule, if they actually use it. It is not a reward for a pretty house, and it is not the percent you use because the seller will not take the lower number. Paying 75 percent when your buyer pays 70 percent means you are the one funding the $11,000. On the first deal that is the difference between buying at $114,000 and buying at $125,000. Your rehab did not shrink to pay for it.
There is a third screen people mix in: 25/5/3, which keeps 67 percent of ARV and then subtracts rehab. On the $220,000 ARV the reserves are profit $55,000, closing $11,000, and holding $6,600, a total of $72,600. The offer is $220,000 minus $40,000 minus $72,600, which is $107,400. That is $6,600 under the 70 percent offer of $114,000, and $17,600 under the 75 percent offer of $125,000. Three different ceilings. Name the one your buyer uses before you write a contract. The page on when the 70 percent price is still too high starts from the 70 percent number and then adds costs the percent never itemized. A 75 percent price has even less room for those costs, because you already gave away five more points.
Rounding does not create these gaps. Every product here is a whole number of dollars before the subtraction, so the single rounding step does not move the result. If an ARV times 0.70 is not a whole number, the offer rounds once after rehab is subtracted, not before. These examples were chosen so that step is exact and you can see the 5 percent with no rounding dust. The figures are invented. They are not a buyer’s letter of intent.
Questions
Why is the gap $11,000 on the first example?
Five percent of a $220,000 after-repair value is $11,000. The 75 percent price keeps those five points and the 70 percent price does not. Rehab is subtracted from both, so it is not part of the $11,000.
Should a wholesaler use the buyer 75 percent number as their own ceiling?
Only if that buyer is the one who will close. A 75 percent end buyer raises the fee room by 5 percent of ARV. Your own 70 percent screen is a different ceiling. Using the higher one when your buyer uses the lower one overstates the contract you can sign.
run a full analysis free when the median you can do by hand is not enough. A full analysis weights the comps, adjusts beds and baths, and prices the repair tiers. The sample figures there are invented, the same way every dollar on this page is invented.