Flip profit margin versus the profit reserve
Margin on a flip gets used for three different numbers, and the worksheet only works if you keep them apart. The profit reserve in the 25/5/3 offer is 25 percent of after-repair value. Dollar profit is what remains after purchase, rehab, buyer closing, holding, and seller closing. ROI is that dollar profit divided by the cash in, excluding seller closing, rounded to one decimal percent. This page computes all three on one invented deal so the words stop standing in for each other. The flip profit guide already walks a different purchase price and lands on $48,360 and 34.6 percent. This page does not repeat that deal.
The lines
After-repair value is $240,000. Purchase is $110,000. Rehab is $48,000. The hold is 6 months. Buyer closing is 3 percent of the purchase price, which is $3,300. Seller closing is 6 percent of ARV, which is $14,400. Holding is 0.5 percent of the purchase price per month, times 6, which is $3,300. Monthly holding, for a sense of the run rate, is $550. Cash in is purchase plus rehab plus buyer closing plus holding: $110,000 plus $48,000 plus $3,300 plus $3,300, which is $164,600. Seller closing is not in that total. It comes off the sale. Net proceeds are $240,000 minus $14,400, which is $225,600. Profit is $225,600 minus $164,600, which is $61,000.
ROI is $61,000 divided by $164,600. That quotient times 1,000 is 370.595, which rounds to 371, then divided by 10 is 37.1 percent. The 25 percent reserve on the ARV is $60,000. Profit is $61,000. ROI is 37.1 percent. Three numbers, three jobs. The $60,000 is a planning cushion you subtract when you are still choosing what to pay. The $61,000 is the leftover after you chose $110,000 and held for six months. The 37.1 percent is that leftover compared with the cash that was tied up. Saying the margin is “about 25 percent” erases the only one of the three that is a return on capital.
Where the purchase price came from
The 70 percent offer on this ARV and this rehab is $168,000 minus $48,000, which is $120,000. The example purchase is $110,000, which is $10,000 under that offer. Part of the $61,000 profit is that $10,000. Pay $120,000 instead and buyer closing becomes $3,600, holding becomes $3,600, cash in becomes $175,200, profit becomes $50,400, and ROI becomes 28.8 percent. I will not pretend that second ROI is this deal. It is the sensitivity. The ARV and 70% rule calculator gives you the $120,000 ceiling. It does not compute the $61,000. The MAO calculator gives the 25/5/3 ceiling: profit reserve $60,000, closing reserve $12,000, holding reserve $7,200, offer $240,000 minus $48,000 minus those reserves, which is $112,800. The example paid $110,000, which is $2,800 under that ceiling. Close to the ceiling is not the same statement as “ROI is 25 percent.”
Check the sensitivity arithmetic so it does not float. Purchase $120,000. Buyer closing $3,600. Holding $120,000 times 0.005 times 6 is $3,600. Cash in is $120,000 plus $48,000 plus $3,600 plus $3,600, which is $175,200. Net proceeds stay $225,600. Profit is $50,400. $50,400 divided by $175,200 times 1,000 is 287.671, which rounds to 288, divided by 10 is 28.8 percent. The page on a 70 percent price that is still too high starts from paying the screen and then adds a fee. This page starts from paying under the screen and then names the profit. Read them as a pair, not as two versions of one worksheet.
What not to call the margin
Do not call the gap between ARV and purchase the margin. That gap here is $130,000, and it still has to pay rehab, both closings, and holding. Do not call the 25 percent reserve your ROI. Do not call 37.1 percent “25 percent, close enough” when you are comparing two deals. A deal at 37.1 percent on $164,600 and a deal at 28.8 percent on $175,200 are different piles of profit, $61,000 versus $50,400, and the percents alone hide the dollars. These inputs are invented. The rates are the flip projection’s rates: 3 percent, 6 percent, and 0.5 percent a month.
Questions
Is the 25 percent profit reserve the same as ROI?
No. The reserve is 25 percent of the $240,000 ARV, which is $60,000, and it is subtracted to shape an offer. ROI on this example is profit of $61,000 divided by cash in of $164,600, which rounds to 37.1 percent. The percents are not interchangeable.
Why is profit $61,000 if the reserve was $60,000?
Because the purchase price in the example is $110,000, which is under the 70 percent offer, and profit is what remains after closing and holding. The reserve never promised that the leftover would equal 25 percent of ARV.
run a full analysis free when the median you can do by hand is not enough. A full analysis weights the comps, adjusts beds and baths, and prices the repair tiers. The sample figures there are invented, the same way every dollar on this page is invented.