Kitchen and bath rehab budget
Searchers looking for a kitchen and bath budget usually want a second price list: one number for the kitchen, one for each bath, added to whatever the rest of the house costs. The tier model does not work that way. The moderate base is $40 per square foot before age and type, and that tier is already the kitchen, the baths, the floors, and the finishes that go with a middle scope. Adding a kitchen allowance on top prices the kitchen twice. This page uses an invented 1,500 square foot house at a factor of 1.00 so the moderate total is $60,000, and an invented extra allowance of $35,000 that does not come from a city table.
One tier, one total
Fifteen hundred square feet times $40 is $60,000. That is the repair number if the scope is moderate and the factors are 1. The cosmetic page is the $20 tier on a different size. If your kitchen and baths are a refresh inside a light scope, you are on that page, not this one. If they are a full replacement inside a middle scope, the $60,000 already includes them. The scope checklist is how you decide which sentence is true. A checklist that says “new kitchen” does not automatically mean “new kitchen plus the moderate total.”
After-repair value is an invented $220,000. Seventy percent is $154,000. With rehab at $60,000, the offer is $94,000. With the extra $35,000 stacked on, rehab is $95,000 and the offer is $154,000 minus $95,000, which is $59,000. The offer fell by $35,000. Nothing about the house changed between those two sentences except that the kitchen was written down twice. The ARV and 70% rule calculator will obediently print both offers. It does not know the $35,000 is the same rooms.
When a separate line is legitimate
A separate line is legitimate when it is outside the tier. A failed sewer, a foundation, or a total roof that the moderate description does not include can be an inspect-and-price line added once. It is not a second kitchen. The pre-1960 guide keeps those lines as inspections rather than as a national add-on table. If you add a real outside line, add it once and say what it is. Do not label it “kitchen” to make the double count feel like diligence.
The 25/5/3 offer on the clean $60,000 budget is a different screen, not a different kitchen. Profit on $220,000 is $55,000. Closing is $11,000. Holding is $6,600. The offer is $220,000 minus $60,000 minus $55,000 minus $11,000 minus $6,600, which is $87,400. The 70 percent offer was $94,000. The gap is $6,600, 3 percent of ARV. Stacking the $35,000 drops the 25/5/3 offer to $52,400 as well. Both screens punish the double count by the same dollars. The MAO calculator is where those reserves are itemized. Fix the rehab input before you blame the percent.
Age factors do not create a kitchen line either
If this 1,500 square foot house is 30 years old, the age factor is 1.15 and the moderate rate rounds to $46. The total is $69,000, not $60,000 plus a kitchen. The extra $9,000 is the age factor on the whole tier, including the kitchen that was already in the tier. Adding a $35,000 kitchen on top of $69,000 is the same double count, $9,000 more expensive. Pick one path: the factored tier, or a real bid that replaces the tier. Not both, and not the tier plus a souvenir allowance.
Baths follow the same rule as the kitchen. A house with two baths does not get two bath prices on top of $40 a foot. The square footage already got larger if the baths made the house larger, and the tier already contemplated the fixtures. These allowances and this ARV are invented. The $40 base is the product’s base. There is no city kitchen price on this page.
Questions
Should I add a separate kitchen price on top of the moderate tier?
Not if the moderate tier is already your scope for those rooms. On this house the tier is $60,000. An extra invented $35,000 allowance makes the budget $95,000 and cuts the offer by $35,000. That is the same work priced twice.
Is $35,000 a published kitchen cost?
No. It is an invented allowance used to show the double count. This page has no city price table.
run a full analysis free when the median you can do by hand is not enough. A full analysis weights the comps, adjusts beds and baths, and prices the repair tiers. The sample figures there are invented, the same way every dollar on this page is invented.