Rehab contingency on a flip

A rehab contingency is a percent of the repair budget you add because the walkthrough was not the whole truth. It is not a fourth reserve next to profit, closing, and holding, and it is not a reason to change 70 percent into some other percent. You add it to rehab. Rehab is subtracted once. The offer falls by the dollars you added. This page uses an invented ARV of $200,000 and an invented base rehab of $40,000, the same pair the MAO calculator uses as its sample, so the contingency is the only new moving part.

Ten percent

Ten percent of $40,000 is $4,000. The rehab you should type is $44,000, not $40,000 with a mental note. Seventy percent of $200,000 is $140,000. Minus $40,000 the offer is $100,000. Minus $44,000 the offer is $96,000. The $4,000 left the offer in full. There is no second place the contingency hides. If you leave the form at $40,000 and tell yourself you “have 10 percent in your head,” the form is offering $100,000 for a job you already priced at $44,000. The ARV and 70% rule calculator will show $96,000 as soon as the rehab field says 44000.

The 25/5/3 offer moves by the same $4,000. On $40,000 of rehab it is $94,000. On $44,000 of rehab it is $90,000. Profit, closing, and holding are percents of ARV, so they stay at $50,000, $10,000, and $6,000. Only the repair line changed. People who add a contingency and also fatten the holding reserve are budgeting the unknown twice. Pick the line that the unknown belongs to. Hidden conditions in the house belong to rehab. Extra months on the market belong to holding. They are not interchangeable just because both make the offer smaller.

Fifteen percent lands on a familiar number

Fifteen percent of $40,000 is $6,000. Rehab becomes $46,000. The 70 percent offer is $140,000 minus $46,000, which is $94,000. That $94,000 is also the 25/5/3 offer on the original $40,000 rehab. The match is a coincidence of these particular inputs. It is not evidence that a 15 percent contingency and the 25/5/3 formula are the same idea. One of them changed the job from $40,000 to $46,000 and kept the 70 percent screen. The other kept the job at $40,000 and used a tighter screen. A reader who says “15 percent contingency gets me to the MAO” has confused a shared dollar amount with a shared meaning.

Zero contingency is allowed when the scope is a bid rather than a tier. A tier total from square footage is a model, and a model is a reason to carry contingency. A signed bid that already includes the contractor’s own contingency is a reason not to add another 10 percent on top, or you will subtract the unknown twice. The scope checklist is how you tell a model from a bid. The per-foot guide is the model. If you use the model, the contingency goes on the model’s output. If you use the bid, read whether the bid already padded itself.

Where contingency does not belong

Do not put contingency into the ARV. Raising a $200,000 median to $204,000 because repairs might run over is the wrong direction and the wrong variable. Cost risk lowers what you pay. It does not raise what the repaired house is worth. Do not put it into the assignment fee either. A fee is what is left under the buyer’s ceiling after the contract. If you hide $4,000 of contingency inside a fatter fee, the end buyer’s rehab is still short and the deal comes back. The assignment fee guide prices the fee from the ceiling. Give that ceiling the $44,000 rehab, not the $40,000 rehab.

A contingency percent you cannot name is not a percent. Ten percent of a budget you have not written is ten percent of a guess, and the $4,000 looks precise anyway. Write the $40,000 as a list of rooms first. Then take 10 percent of that list. These dollars are invented so $4,000 and $6,000 divide cleanly. They are not a reserve requirement from a lender. A sheet that applies a contingency rate you can edit, on a different invented example, is the fix and flip spreadsheet.

Questions

Does a 10 percent contingency change the 70 percent rule itself?

No. The rule stays at 0.70. The contingency raises the rehab from $40,000 to $44,000, and the offer falls by $4,000. You changed the input, not the percent.

Why does 15 percent land on $94,000?

Fifteen percent of $40,000 is $6,000, so rehab becomes $46,000 and the 70 percent offer is $94,000. The 25/5/3 offer on the original $40,000 rehab is also $94,000. Same dollars, different formulas. Do not treat that match as a reason to prefer 15 percent.

run a full analysis free when the median you can do by hand is not enough. A full analysis weights the comps, adjusts beds and baths, and prices the repair tiers. The sample figures there are invented, the same way every dollar on this page is invented.