The 1% rule and a BRRRR rent estimate
The 1 percent rule, as people search for it, says monthly rent should be at least 1 percent of the purchase price. The rent line in this product is not that test. It averages 1 percent of after-repair value with $1.25 per square foot of living area, each piece rounded, then the average rounded. A BRRRR worksheet that mixes the two will accept and reject the same house for reasons that are not in the report. This page uses invented inputs and keeps them in both formulas so the disagreement is arithmetic, not a vibe.
One rent estimate
After-repair value is $200,000. Living area is 1,500 square feet. Rent from value is $2,000. Rent from size is $1,875. The average rounds to $1,938 a month. That is the rent estimate. It does not look at the purchase price. The cap rate guide uses this rent with a 45 percent expense share. The BRRRR cash-on-cash path uses the same rent with a 50 percent expense share. Neither path divides the rent by the purchase price and asks for 1 percent.
The screen on two purchase prices
Purchase is $120,000. One percent of that is $1,200 a month. The rent estimate of $1,938 divided by $120,000 is 1.615 percent. The screen passes, by a lot, and it passed because the purchase was far under the ARV, not because the rent formula checked the purchase. Replace the purchase with $200,000 and leave the ARV and the square feet alone. The rent estimate is still $1,938. One percent of $200,000 is $2,000. The rent is $62 short of that screen. $1,938 divided by $200,000 is 0.969 percent. The house did not get worse. The denominator changed. A rule that flips from pass to fail when you pay more for the same rent is a statement about price, which is useful, and it is not a statement about the rent estimate.
The cash-left page uses the $1,938 rent, the $120,000 purchase, and a $50,000 rehab. Cash left there is $20,000 and the yield on those dollars is 58.1 percent. None of that division is the 1 percent screen. You can pass 1 percent of purchase and still have cash stuck after a 75 percent refinance, which is what that page is about. You can also fail 1 percent of a high purchase and still have the refinance return every dollar, if the ARV supports the loan. The screens are not substitutes.
Do not paste one percent into the other formula
If you take 1 percent of the $120,000 purchase, you have $1,200, and if you then run the 50 percent expense share on $1,200 you have $7,200 a year of net. That is not the report. The report’s annual net on $1,938 is $1,938 times 12 times 0.5, which is $11,628. Using $7,200 understates the formula’s income by $4,428 a year on this example, and it does so by answering a question the formula did not ask. The MAO calculator will not compute rent at all. The ARV and 70% rule calculator will not either. A 70 percent offer on the $200,000 ARV with $50,000 of rehab is $90,000. One percent of that $90,000 purchase would be $900 of rent, which the $1,938 estimate clears even more easily. The offer changed the screen again without touching the rent.
Zero square feet is the odd case in the rent estimate. Both pieces use 1 percent of ARV, so the result is that 1 percent figure, $2,000 on this ARV. The 1 percent of purchase screen still does not care. A signed lease does not care about either estimate. If you have a lease, the lease is the rent, and both of these numbers are a model you can put down. These purchase prices, this ARV, and this size are invented. The two formulas are the ones people confuse, written so the percents can be checked. Neither formula prices a loan payment. That payment is on the BRRRR calculator.
Questions
Does the report check that rent is 1 percent of the purchase price?
No. The rent estimate averages 1 percent of after-repair value with $1.25 per square foot. The 1 percent of purchase screen is a different test people bring in from outside. This page puts both on the same invented deal.
Can the same rent pass one test and fail the other?
Yes. At a $120,000 purchase, $1,938 is 1.615 percent, which clears 1 percent. At a $200,000 purchase, the rent estimate is still $1,938 if ARV and size did not change, and $1,938 is 0.969 percent of $200,000, which misses 1 percent.
run a full analysis free when the median you can do by hand is not enough. A full analysis weights the comps, adjusts beds and baths, and prices the repair tiers. The sample figures there are invented, the same way every dollar on this page is invented.