BRRRR cash left in the deal

Cash left in a BRRRR deal is purchase plus rehab minus the new loan, when that difference is positive. The new loan in this formula is 75 percent of after-repair value, rounded to the nearest dollar. Cash-on-cash uses a 50 percent expense share on the rent estimate, and only the dollars still stuck get a percent. This page keeps the purchase and rehab from the second example on the refinance guide and changes the living area, so you can see the yield move while the cash left does not. The 1 percent screen is a different test and is not used here.

The inputs that match, and the one that does not

After-repair value is $200,000. Purchase is $120,000. Rehab is $50,000. Cash in is $170,000. The loan is 75 percent of $200,000, which is $150,000. Cash back is zero. Cash left is $170,000 minus $150,000, which is $20,000. That much is the same as the refinance guide. Living area here is 1,500 square feet, not 1,200. Rent from ARV is 1 percent of $200,000, which is $2,000. Rent from size is 1,500 times $1.25, which is $1,875. Monthly rent is the rounded average, $1,938. The refinance guide’s 1,200 square feet produced $1,500 from size and a $1,750 rent. Same ARV, different area, different rent.

The yield on the dollars still in

A year of the $1,938 rent is $23,256. Half of that, the 50 percent expense share, is $11,628 of annual net. Cash-on-cash is $11,628 divided by the $20,000 left in. That quotient times 1,000 is 581.4, which rounds to 581, then divided by 10 is 58.1 percent. The refinance guide’s $1,750 rent produced $10,500 of annual net and 52.5 percent on the same $20,000. The 5.6 point difference is the living area, not a different loan and not a different purchase. Quote 58.1 percent on the $20,000 left in. Do not quote it on the $170,000 you wired.

The loan payment is not in this percent. Fifty-eight point one percent can sit next to a monthly payment that eats the rent, and the formula will not say so, because it has no interest rate. A fully returned deal, such as the refinance guide’s first example with $16,000 of cash back, does not get a yield percent at all. There the loan covered every dollar of purchase plus rehab and sent cash home. Dividing income by zero dollars left in is not zero percent and not an infinite percent. This page is the other branch: money is still stuck, so a percent exists, and the percent is easy to over-read.

What would clear the $20,000

The loan would have to reach $170,000. That is 85 percent of the $200,000 ARV, and this formula does not lend 85 percent. It lends 75 percent. You clear the $20,000 by lowering cash in, not by wishing the percent were higher. Ten thousand dollars less rehab makes cash in $160,000 and cash left $10,000. The rent does not change, so annual net stays $11,628, and the yield becomes $11,628 divided by $10,000, which rounds to 116.3 percent. The deal did not get twice as good. The denominator got smaller. A tiny amount left in the deal prints a wild percent. That is a reason to say the dollars left in first and the percent second.

Check that 116.3: $11,628 divided by $10,000 is 1.1628, times 1,000 is 1,162.8, which rounds to 1,163, divided by 10 is 116.3. I am not recommending the lower rehab. I am showing the percent’s sensitivity. The MAO calculator did not produce the $120,000 purchase. A 70 percent offer on this ARV with $50,000 of rehab is $140,000 minus $50,000, which is $90,000. Buying at $120,000 is $30,000 above that screen. The cash left is partly the decision to pay above the screen. The ARV and 70% rule calculator will show the $90,000 if you give it a $200,000 median and $50,000 of rehab. The refinance math then has to be rerun, because a $90,000 purchase and a $50,000 rehab is $140,000 of cash in, under the $150,000 loan, which is cash back of $10,000 and no yield percent.

These figures are invented. They use the same rent estimate and the same 75 percent loan as the report. They are not an appraisal and not a term sheet. Closing costs are not inside cash in. If you paid them in cash, add them to the purchase before you trust the $20,000. A loan payment, which this page does not price, is on the BRRRR calculator.

Questions

Why is this 58.1 percent when the refinance guide says 52.5 percent?

The cash left is the same $20,000, from a $120,000 purchase and a $50,000 rehab against a $150,000 loan. The refinance guide uses 1,200 square feet and a $1,750 rent. This page uses 1,500 square feet and a $1,938 rent. The yield moved because the rent moved.

Is 58.1 percent the return on the $170,000 you spent?

No. It is the return on the $20,000 still in the deal. The other $150,000 came back as debt. The formula does not subtract the loan payment from the rent.

run a full analysis free when the median you can do by hand is not enough. A full analysis weights the comps, adjusts beds and baths, and prices the repair tiers. The sample figures there are invented, the same way every dollar on this page is invented.